Certainly, music and the arts as a whole have a crossover point . The Gaudia Vaisnava acaryas use music as do the Christians , the Islamic faiths, and the Jewish faith.
Arts of all kinds are used to tell of the spiritual dimensions and the divine varigatedness of spiritual relationships and their beauty, which far exceed the self-centred relationships of this world. Every faith has allowances and restrictions within the world of art , art is a perfect tool for spiritual connections or it can hopelessly and helplessly bind one to a temporarily manifested world where the ignorant strongly identify with the sensual world centred around unrestricted sex .
Only an unthinking fanatic would want to ban music and singing as a form of glorification of God , but certainly there are prohibitions , music should be solely a glorification of God and the progressive cultures He teaches , it should not be music that promotes oneself in any way or any enjoyments in a temporarily manifested world based on sensual relationship that come and go .
This is said in Islamic faith , both Srila Bhaktisiddanta Sarasvati Goswami Maharaja and Srila AC Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada had some restrictions on how music and the arts are to be conducted. Before the Renaissance, everything in cultures and educational matters was solely meant for Divinity in music, arts, sciences, social sciences, and political science. There is a careful balance to be struck .
“The status of music in Islam is a subject of extensive debate among scholars, and there is no single consensus. Different schools of thought interpret the Quran and Hadith in varying ways, leading to three main perspectives.1. The Prohibitive View (Haram)Many classical and conservative scholars consider music and musical instruments to be forbidden (haram).Evidence: They cite Hadiths (recorded sayings of the Prophet Muhammad) that condemn instruments.Quranic Interpretation: Verses such as Surah Luqman (31:6) that warn against “idle talk” (lahwal-hadith) are interpreted by some early commentators as references to singing and music.Reasoning: The belief that music distracts from the remembrance of God, encourages heedlessness, and can lead to sinful environments.2. The Permissible View (Halal)Other scholars argue that music is generally permissible, provided the content does not promote immorality or lead to the neglect of religious duties.Evidence: “
The Vedas and the Sankirtana movements are full of appropriate music , as is the case with most faiths .
More on this soon .
http://www.thevedicspectator.com
Site Title 