The implications of Srila Bhaktisiddhanta pointing out the calculations of astrology by not understanding moving planets

+5

“Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Saraswati Thakura’s pointing out the flaws in astrological calculations, particularly regarding the failure to properly account for the 

precession of the equinoxes (the moving zodiac/ayanamsa) versus the fixed stars (sidereal), has several significant implications. His, and later A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada’s, critiques were aimed at shifting the focus from material fatalism to absolute dependence on spiritual, transcendental activity. 

Here are the key implications of his stance:

• Correction of “Fixed” vs. “Moving” Planets (Ayanamsa): Bhaktisiddhanta Saraswati highlighted that conventional astrology often ignored the shift between the tropical (ayan) and sidereal (nirayan) zodiacs. By insisting on precise, mathematically sound calculations (as in the Surya-siddhanta), he underscored that neglecting the precession of the equinoxes (the moving planets/constellations) makes astronomical calculations outdated and inaccurate.
• Marginalization of Fate and Materialism: The fundamental implication is that relying on astrological charts, which are based on “material karma,” is a sign of immature understanding. He emphasized that a devotee is not bound by mundane stellar influences. Astrology, at best, applies to the material body, but the soul is free.
• Emphasis on “Transcending” Rather than “Managing” Karma: Instead of using astrology to calculate the best time for material actions (a key focus in the materialist world), Bhaktisiddhanta taught that one should transcend planetary influence altogether through surrender to God (Krishna).
• The Inadequacy of “Blind” Astrology: By highlighting these calculation errors, he pointed out that many practitioners of astrology are incompetent, leading people to “bogus” conclusions.
• Superiority of Spiritual Action: The ultimate implication is that the Sankirtan movement (congregational chanting) is the only truly effective “remedy” in the Kali-yuga, as it directly acts on the soul and alters destiny, rendering even “accurate” astrological predictions unnecessary. “
• Many devotees overly account for their astrological situation,  desperately trying to avoid suffering and gain happiness. The Smarta Brahminism sort overly relies on wrong tools and does not have faith or understanding of what devotional activities do for one . Although Prabhupada said, “Clap your hands before the Deities everything changes “
• http://www.thevedicspectator.com